An electronic health record system is an electronic record of health-related information on an individual that includes patient demographic and clinical health information, such as medical history and problem lists, and has the capacity to provide clinical decision support, support physician order entry, capture and query information relevant to health care quality, and exchange electronic health information with, and integrate such information from, other sources [2][3]. The Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) maintains this Base EHR definition, which establishes the minimum capabilities that certified systems must meet [2]. In practice, organizations evaluating EHR systems are choosing among products that satisfy this baseline while differing in hosting architecture, workflow configuration, and the degree to which they fit a specific practice's needs. The selection process is not a matter of picking the most recognizable vendor; it requires assessing readiness, defining information needs, and testing candidate systems against documented scenarios [1][4]. This guide explains the regulatory definition, the practical distinction between cloud-based and locally hosted EHRs, and a concrete evaluation sequence drawn from ONC resources.

The Base EHR Definition Sets a Functional Floor

The Base EHR definition in 45 CFR § 170.102 describes an electronic record of health-related information on an individual that includes patient demographic and clinical health information, such as medical history and problem lists [3]. The definition also requires the capacity to provide clinical decision support, support physician order entry, capture and query information relevant to health care quality, and exchange electronic health information with, and integrate such information from, other sources [3]. These are capacities, not guarantees of clinical outcomes. A system that meets the definition can perform these functions, but the definition does not establish that any particular implementation will reduce errors or improve care in a specific setting.

ONC publishes the certification criteria that operationalize the Base EHR definition. For calendar year 2025 and 2026, the required criteria include demographics under § 170.315(a)(5), implantable device list under § 170.315(a)(14), decision support interventions under § 170.315(b)(11), computerized provider order entry under § 170.315(a)(1), (2) or (3), clinical quality measures record and export under § 170.315(c)(1), and transitions of care under § 170.315(b)(1) [2]. The requirements can be met using one Certified Health IT Module or a combination of Certified Health IT Modules [2]. This modular structure means an organization may assemble a certified EHR from multiple components rather than purchasing a single monolithic product.

Cloud-Based and Locally Hosted EHRs Present Different Operational Burdens

Cloud-based EHRs run on cloud-computing platforms. ONC lists higher levels of IT service availability than in-house IT services and fewer run-time failures such as slow performance or application freezing among the common benefits [1][4]. Organizations can start small and increase IT allocations as needed [1]. However, responsibility for data security is shared between the organization and the cloud EHR vendor, and the organization has less data access and control compared to a locally hosted EHR [1][4]. These tradeoffs are documented by ONC as common benefits and challenges, not as universal outcomes for every deployment.

Locally hosted EHRs keep software and data on server computers at the practice [1][4]. ONC identifies benefits including less investment in internet connection upgrades if the practice does not already have reliable, high-speed internet access, and the fact that the organization does not have to trust an outside organization with the security of patients' data [4]. The challenges are also concrete: the organization is responsible for making sure servers are physically secure, performing regular data backups, and covering the costs associated with equipment purchase and maintenance [4]. The choice between these models depends on existing infrastructure, staffing, and risk tolerance, not on a universal ranking of one approach over the other.

A Concrete Evaluation Sequence for a Small Practice

A small practice could follow this documented sequence. First, assess readiness and information needs using the ONC readiness factors, including personnel eagerness and the availability of someone to lead the effort [1]. Second, use the CHPL to identify certified products that meet the Base EHR criteria for the applicable reporting year [2][6]. Third, run the ONC demonstration scenario with two or three vendors, asking each to show how the system handles demographics, implantable device list, decision support, order entry, and transitions of care [2][4]. Fourth, use the Vendor Comparison Tool to record answers to suggested demo questions and the Vendor Pricing Template to define line-item costs [1]. Fifth, use the EHR System Testing Plan to track performance tests across the candidate systems [4]. This sequence uses ONC's documented tools, but the final choice remains specific to the practice's workflow, infrastructure, and staffing.

Selection Requires Readiness Assessment Before Vendor Comparison

ONC identifies common implementation roadblocks: incomplete understanding of the organization's information needs, uncertain costs, and the effort required to identify and implement an appropriate EHR system [1][4]. Before getting started, organizations should assess readiness, personnel eagerness, availability of someone to lead the effort, stakeholders who perceive EHRs as useful, and ability to work as a team [1][4]. Planning must address both the initial and ongoing effects that EHR implementation will have on the clinical practice [1][4]. These factors are prerequisites to vendor evaluation, not optional considerations.

The Health IT Playbook directs organizations to a six-step module for selecting EHR software and vendors, emphasizing that EHR systems are not one-size-fits-all [1]. Clinicians, other healthcare providers, and staff need to consider their practice's specific needs and resources [1]. ONC also maintains the Certified Health IT Product List (CHPL), a comprehensive list of products that have been successfully tested by an Accredited Testing Laboratory and certified by an ONC-Authorized Certification Body [6]. The CHPL User Guide describes how organizations can search for certified products [6]. Certification gives assurance that a system meets technological capability, functionality, and security requirements adopted by HHS, but it does not by itself establish that a product fits a particular practice's workflow [7].

A Documented Demonstration Scenario Can Expose Workflow Fit

ONC publishes an EHR Demonstration Scenario, Evaluation, and Vendor Questions resource to help clinicians, other healthcare providers, and health IT implementers understand vendor capabilities [4]. The resource is designed for use when selecting or upgrading to an EHR [4]. A separate EHR Selection Tool includes an interactive guide, case studies, definitions, and an EHR-selection matrix to help select EHR functionalities from 10 major categories, particularly for long-term and post-acute care settings [4]. These tools structure the evaluation around observable capabilities rather than marketing claims.

As a suggested workflow, an ambulatory practice could use the demonstration scenario to test how a candidate system handles a patient with multiple chronic conditions and an implantable device. The evaluation team would ask the vendor to show how the system captures the unique device identifier for the implantable device, records the assessment and plan of treatment, and exchanges a transition of care record with a specialist [2][3]. The team would then document whether the system performed these tasks without manual workarounds. This is a suggestion for how to apply ONC's documented resources; it is not a test that ONC has validated, and the results would apply only to that practice's configuration and the specific vendor demonstration.

Certification, Interoperability, and Safety Guides Shape Ongoing Management

The ONC Health IT Certification Program gives assurance to EHR purchasers and other users that a system meets the technological capability, functionality, and security requirements adopted by HHS [7]. Certified EHR Technology (CEHRT) includes, at a minimum, the capabilities outlined in the Base EHR Definition, and additional certified functionality may be necessary to meet program-specific objectives, measures, or reporting requirements [2]. Participants should confirm CEHRT requirements for their applicable program and reporting year [2]. This means certification status is a baseline check, not the end of due diligence.

SAFER Guides address the management and monitoring protocols, policies, and practices required to enhance the safety of the EHR's technical components [8]. The System Management guide focuses on configuration, validation, and maintenance of EHR hardware, software, and system-to-system application programming interfaces [8]. It recommends that current versions of the EHR application software and associated operating systems, cybersecurity protections, software applications, interface protocols, and clinical vocabularies are implemented [8]. The guide also recommends that the EHR use standardized data interchange protocols and clinical and administrative terminologies for exchanging data between internal and external computer systems, adhering to national recommendations when possible [8]. These practices are informational and do not guarantee compliance with HIPAA or other laws [8].