Comparing transport ventilators for procurement requires separating the clinical transport problem from the device specification sheet. The useful starting point is not a list of modes, but the setting in which the ventilator will operate: intra-hospital movement, inter-hospital emergency transfer, prehospital field care, or military en route care. Each setting imposes different constraints on oxygen supply, battery duration, altitude, and operator training. AARC guidance states that the preferred method of ventilation during transport is a transport ventilator, and that a trial using the planned device should be conducted before transport whenever possible [1]. Procurement teams should therefore evaluate devices against a defined transport scenario, then use bench and usability evidence to test whether the device can perform under the respiratory mechanics and interface conditions that scenario will actually produce. The citations in this article use the source numbers listed in the reference set: [1] AARC position statement, [2] Scientific Reports usability study, [3] Hamilton Medical prehospital checklist, [4] ZOLL EMV+ product page, [5] Critical Care bench study, and [6] Annals of Intensive Care bench study. This article outlines that workflow and applies it to documented examples without declaring a universal winner.
Define the transport setting before comparing specifications
The first decision point is whether the device must support intra-hospital transport, inter-hospital emergency transfer, or field and military use. AARC defines inter-hospital transport as emergency movement between facilities for acute life-threatening illness, while intra-hospital transport occurs within a single facility [1]. These categories are not interchangeable. A device selected for short intra-hospital moves may not need the rugged housing, altitude compensation, or extended battery runtime required for air or ground inter-facility transfer. Procurement teams should write the transport scenario first, including expected duration, vehicle type, and the clinical team that will operate the device.
The gas and power environment is the second constraint. Some transport ventilators are compressor-driven and can operate without a high-pressure oxygen source, while pneumatic devices depend on oxygen supply behavior that changes with source pressure and selected oxygen fraction. The Annals of Intensive Care bench study notes that transport ventilators requiring only one oxygen source may be used in places with limited air and oxygen pressure sources [6]. A procurement comparison should therefore record whether the candidate device is turbine or pneumatic, what oxygen sources it accepts, and how autonomy changes at different oxygen fractions. These are operational constraints, not secondary features.
Use bench data to compare delivered ventilation under defined mechanics
Bench testing provides the most reproducible basis for comparing technical performance because it holds respiratory mechanics constant across devices. The 2014 Critical Care study evaluated 26 emergency and transport ventilators under compliance values of 30, 70, and 120 mL/cmH2O, resistance values of 5, 10, and 20 cmH2O/mL/s, and leak levels from 3.5 to 12.5 L/min [5]. The authors classified devices into ICU-like, sophisticated, simple, and mass-casualty or military categories, and reported that several cheaper devices performed at least equally to more sophisticated and expensive ones within adjacent categories [5]. Procurement teams can use this structure to compare devices within a category rather than across unrelated price or capability tiers.
A more focused comparison of four transport ventilators and one ICU ventilator under simulated severe respiratory conditions found measurable differences in trigger delay and delivered volume error [6]. The study reported trigger delays of 50 ms for the Engström Carestation, 71 ms for the Osiris 3, 132 ms for the Oxylog 3000, 60 ms for the Monnal T60, and 67 ms for the Elisee 350 when grouping two inspiratory effort conditions [6]. These figures are bench measurements, not clinical outcomes, but they allow a procurement team to ask vendors for comparable test conditions. A comparison should request the same compliance, resistance, leak, and effort settings for every candidate device.
A suggested evaluation workflow for a hospital transport program
One defensible workflow is to define a representative scenario, such as a 90-minute inter-facility transfer of an intubated adult with moderate ARDS, then test each candidate device under that scenario. The team would first confirm that the device can deliver the required tidal volume and PEEP under the expected compliance and resistance, using bench conditions similar to those reported in the Critical Care study [5]. The team would then run a pre-transport trial on a stable patient, as AARC recommends, to assess tolerance and stability with the planned device [1]. Finally, the team would complete a structured interface task evaluation with the clinicians who will operate the device, recording task failures and time to completion rather than relying on subjective preference [2]. This workflow produces comparable evidence for each candidate without requiring a universal ranking.
Evaluate interface usability as a patient safety variable
Interface design affects whether operators can complete tasks accurately under time pressure. A 2026 Scientific Reports study used eye tracking and a standardized usability questionnaire to compare four transport ventilators: the Monnal T60, HAMILTON-T1, Oxylog 3000 plus, and MEDUMAT Transport [2]. The devices differed in control architecture. Two used a touchscreen with an additional navigation knob or function keys, while two used a display without touch functionality and relied on function keys, a navigation knob, or context-sensitive keys [2]. The study identified task-specific shortcomings and described non-intuitive layout as a potential source of delay or task failure [2].
For procurement, usability testing should be tied to the tasks the transport team will actually perform, such as changing tidal volume, adjusting PEEP, or responding to a disconnect alarm. The Scientific Reports authors note that clear and consistent labeling can reduce cognitive workload and the risk of critical incidents [2]. A comparison should therefore include a structured task evaluation with representative operators, not just a vendor demonstration. The same study reported that 24 of 34 operators had prior experience with the Oxylog 3000 plus, which may influence task performance and should be accounted for when interpreting usability results [2].
Match monitoring, alarms, and backup capability to the transport team
AARC minimum standards require real-time measurement of essential parameters during transport and recommend carbon dioxide monitoring for all mechanically ventilated patients to provide information about airway placement and pulmonary blood flow [1]. The standards also require backup equipment, including a self-inflating bag and mask and sufficient oxygen for the duration of transport [1]. A procurement comparison should therefore treat monitoring and backup as part of the ventilator system, not as optional accessories. The question is whether the device provides or integrates with the required monitoring and whether the team can manage a failure without interrupting ventilation.
Alarm behavior and battery function are also part of the safety comparison. AARC states that transport equipment should be able to function from a battery source, with backup equipment available [1]. Vendor documentation for the EMV+ describes a 10-hour battery runtime, recharge to 90 percent in 2 hours, and altitude compensation from -2,000 to 25,000 feet [4]. These are manufacturer claims and should be verified against the procurement scenario. A comparison should ask for documented battery duration at the expected ventilator settings and oxygen fraction, not the maximum runtime under unspecified conditions.
Build a scenario-based comparison matrix with documented limits
A useful procurement comparison replaces a generic feature checklist with a scenario-based matrix. For each candidate device, the matrix should record the transport setting, gas and power constraints, bench performance under defined mechanics, interface task results, monitoring and alarm capability, and the documented limitations of the evidence. The Critical Care bench study itself notes that a mechanical model cannot mimic all complexities of patient-ventilator interaction, and that the ASL5000 test lung does not simulate expiratory efforts [5]. The Annals of Intensive Care study similarly states that bench simulation predicts clinical results with high fidelity based on previous studies, but the lung model remains a standardized simulation rather than a patient [6].
The matrix should also separate vendor claims from independent evidence. For example, ZOLL states that the EMV+ is the only commercial ventilator cleared for use in military vehicles across air, land, and sea, and that it weighs 9.7 pounds [4]. Those are manufacturer claims about regulatory status and design. A procurement team can verify the weight directly and request the relevant airworthiness documentation, but should not treat the marketing statement as independent validation. The comparison should record what is known from bench or usability studies, what is vendor-reported, and what remains untested for the specific patient population and transport route.
Sources & references
- Position Statement Transport of the Mechanically Ventilated, Critically Injured, or Ill, Neonate, Child, or Adult Patient · www.aarc.org
- Qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the usability of transport ventilators using eye tracking | Scientific Reports · www.nature.com
- Prehospital ventilator selection checklist · www.hamilton-medical.com
- EMV+ Portable Ventilator for Military & Civilian Transport · www.zoll.com
- Bench-test comparison of 26 emergency and transport ventilators | Critical Care | Springer Nature Link · link.springer.com
- Reliability and limits of transport-ventilators to safely ventilate severe patients in special surge situations | Annals of Intensive Care | Springer Nature Link · annalsofintensivecare.springeropen.com
- statement-of-respiratory-therapists-as-cardiopulmonary-care-managers.pdf · www.aarc.org
- [PDF] Mechanical Ventilation Basics, 09 Apr 2025 - Joint Trauma System · jts.health.mil